The Battle of the North Atlantic
Great Britain was in peril as the British Air Force battled the German Luftwaffe in the air and at sea the British Navy fought the Germany Navy that sought to sink merchant ships with vital food, supplies and war materials. President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed the Lend-Lease Act into law on March 11, 1941, and soon after convoys traveled through the North Atlantic escorted by American, Canadian and British Navy ships. German U-boats prowled the waters of the North Atlantic hunting for convoys and ships to sink.
President Roosevelt announced on May 27, 1941, an unlimited national emergency in a radio address to the nation. The U.S. Navy in the North Atlantic would receive more ships, planes and personnel to protect convoys and ensure delivery of supplies and aid to Great Britain, but the North Atlantic remained a dangerous place.
The USS Kearney a United States Navy destroyer suffered the loss of eleven sailors when the ship was torpedoed on October 17, 1941, in the North Atlantic by a German U-boat. The eleven sailors were the first Navy personnel killed by enemy action in World War II.
The Reuben James I (DD-245) was torpedoed on October 31, 1941, by a German U-boat and sunk in the North Atlantic. All seven officers and 93 of the 137 enlisted men were killed in the attack and another sailor died of wounds on November 2, 1941, aboard the Niblack (DD-424).
Imperial Japan conducted a devastating sneak attack on December 7, 1941, at Pearl Harbor, Territory of Hawaii (now State of Hawaii).
The United States of America declared war on Japan on December 8, 1941, on Germany and Italy on December 11, 1941, and entered World War II.
Operation Paukenschlage (Operation Drumbeat)
Nazi Germany wanted to conduct a surprise attack, like Pearl Harbor, on the East Coast of the United States.
Admiral Karl Donitz, Commander of German U-boats, initiated Operation Paukenschlage (Operation Drumbeat) on January 12, 1942, with five German U-boats on patrol from Nova Scotia to the New York Harbor and down to Cape Hatteras, North Carolina. By the end of January 1942, at least 20 merchant ships were sunk off the East Coast of the United States.
- The British merchant steamship Cyclops was torpedoed on January 12, 1942, and sank south of Nova Scotia.
- The Norwegian steam merchant ship Frisco was torpedoed on January 13, 1942, and sank off Nova Scotia.
- The Panamanian steam merchant ship Friar Rock, unarmed and unescorted, was torpedoed on January 13, 1942, and sank off the southwest of Cape Race, Newfoundland.
- The Panamanian motor tanker Norness, unarmed and unescorted, was torpedoed on January 14, 1942, and sank about 50 miles from Montauk Point, Long Island and south of Martha’s Vineyard.
- The British steam tanker Coimbra, an unarmed and unescorted, was torpedoed on January 15, 1942, and sank about 27 miles off Long Island, reportedly the residents of the Hamptons could see the fire from the explosion.
- The American steam tanker SS Allan Jackson, unarmed and unescorted, was torpedoed on January 18, 1942, and sank about 60 miles east-northeast of Diamond Shoals, North Carolina. Unarmed and unescorted.
- The American steam merchant Norvana, unarmed and unescorted, was torpedoed on January 19, 1942, and sank about 50 miles north of Cape Hatteras, North Carolina.
- The American steam merchant City of Atlanta, unescorted and unarmed, was torpedoed on January 19, 1942, and sank about 12 miles south of the Wimble Shoals Buoy and about eight or ten miles off the coast of North Carolina.
- The Canadian steam passenger ship Lady Hawkins, unescorted, was torpedoed on January 19, 1942, and sank about 150 miles east of Cape Hatteras, North Carolina.
- The American steam tanker Malay was torpedoed on January 19, 1942, off Oregon Inlet, North Carolina with a loss of 5 crewmen, the ship under its own power made it to Hampton Roads, Virginia.
- The Latvian steam merchant Ciltvaira, unescorted and unarmed, was torpedoed on January 19, 1942, and sank off Cape Hatteras, North Carolina.
- The Norwegian motor tanker Alexandra Hoegh, unescorted, was torpedoed on January 21, 1942, and sank south of Shelburne, Nova Scotia.
- The Panamanian steam tanker Olympic, unescorted and unarmed, was torpedoed on January 22, 1942, and sank about 70 miles south of Cape Hatteras, North Carolina.
- The Norwegian motor tanker Inneroy, unescorted, was torpedoed on January 22, 1942, and sank south of Nova Scotia and east of Massachusetts.
- The British steam merchant Thirlby, unescorted and unarmed, was torpedoed on January 23, 1942, and sank about 12 miles from Seal Island, Cape Sable, Nova Scotia.
- The British motor tanker Empire Gem, unescorted, was torpedoed on January 24, 1942, and sank about 20 miles southeast of Cape Hatteras, North Carolina.
- The American steam merchant Venore, unescorted and unarmed, that followed the Empire Gem, was torpedoed on January 24, 1942, and sank about 20 miles southeast of Cape Hatteras, North Carolina.
- The Norwegian motor tanker Varanger, unescorted, was torpedoed on January 25, 1942, and sank about 28 miles southeast of Atlantic City, New Jersey.
- The American steam merchant West Ivis was torpedoed on January 26, 1942, and sank some eighty miles southwest of Cape Hatteras, North Carolina.
- The American steam tanker Francis E. Powell, unarmed and unescorted, was torpedoed on January 27, 1942, and sank about eight miles northeast of the Winter Quarter Light vessel stationed off Assateague Island, Virginia.
- The American steam tanker Rochester, unarmed and unescorted, was torpedoed on January 30, 1942, and sank off the Virginia Capes.
Project LQ
All available Navy ships were on convoy or patrol duty in the North Atlantic. A shorthanded Navy considered all options in response to the U-boat attacks off the coast of America.
The Commander in Chief (Cominch), United States Fleet, on January 20, 1942, directed the Commander Eastern Sea Frontier to provide a plan for the manning and fitting-out of Queen ships to be operated as an anti-submarine measure.
Rear Admiral Adolphus Andrews, USN, Commander of the Eastern Sea Frontier, replied on January 29, 1942. The analysis of the attacks concluded that German U-boats were focused on tankers and attacked at night on the surface and from close range. He recommended Q-ships be disguised as tankers and another disguised as a vessel considered insignificant such as a fishing trawler so that a German submarine in the vicinity would not submerge. These decoy ships would operate independently about 200 miles off the eastern coast of the United States. The U.S. Navy was stretched thin, so a decoy ship could not count on a backup to help them.
The Q ships would be outfitted for more reserve buoyancy to remain afloat after being struck by one or two torpedoes. It would also be outfitted with sound gear to detect submarines and armed with main and secondary batteries, and depth charge projectors to attack.
The concept of the operation envisioned a decoy ship disguised as a tanker or fishing trawler would invite attack from a German submarine. The U-boat would fire one or two torpedoes and if struck an experienced crew would provide damage control to keep the ship afloat. It was anticipated that the U-boat to save torpedoes would use gunfire at close range to sink the ship. If submerged the submarine would have to surface to use gunfire at close range. When the U-boat was within range the crew on the decoy ship would attack it with their main and secondary batteries. If the submarine submerged depth charges would be used to destroy it.
Chief of Naval Operations
Rear Admiral Adolphus Andrews memorandum was forwarded to the Chief of Naval Operations on February 15, 1942. The Chief of Naval Operations approved his proposal, and it was named Project LQ. A senior officer on the staff of the Chief of Naval Operations in Washington DC was responsible for obtaining ships, providing the cover story, and finances. It was classified as SECRET, all communications were by word of mouth, and all information was held in classified files in the Vice Chief of Naval Operations.
Rear Admiral Andrews was notified on February 20, 1942, of Project LQ. When the Q ships were ready, they would be assigned to his command of the Eastern Sea Frontier for execution.
Cover Story
A joint account was opened on February 19, 1942, in the Riggs National Bank in Washington DC to pay expenses for the decoy ships in their disguised roles without using Navy requisitions.
The ships would retain their original names but had to be assigned a USS Navy name for naval personnel records, official duty station identification, and a post office address.
The first ships selected would be commissioned by the Commandant, Navy Yard, Portsmouth, New Hampshire, and recorded in the log of that yard, but not made a matter of record at the Navy Department.
When on mission the officers and crew would be wearing civilian or merchant marine clothing and the ship would be identified by her nonmilitary name.
To maintain operational security, if challenged by a friendly ship or aircraft, the decoy ship would identify by the original name and the company that owned it. The SS Carolyn and SS Evelyn were owned by the A.H. Bull Steamship Company.
If an enemy ship was challenged the Q ship reply would be in accordance with International Procedure using the calls and identifications as follows:
ATIK: SS VILL FRANCA, Portuguese Registry, Call CSBT
ASTERION: SS GENERALIFE, Spanish Registry, Call EAOQ
The Commander, Eastern Sea Frontier was to be notified when making a port call who would inform the U.S. Maritime Commission. A commission representative would provide logistics support, and costs would be paid by a check from the Riggs Bank account to the U.S. Maritime Commission.
Operations security at the Naval Shipyard at Portsmouth may have been lacking because reportedly the vessels being converted and outfitted as Q ships was common knowledge in several Portsmouth boarding houses.
Naval Shipyard at Portsmouth
The SS Carolyn and SS Evelyn two commercial cargo vessels owned and operated by the A. H. Bull Steamship Company in New York City were obtained by the Maritime Commission and provided on February 12, 1942, to the United States Navy. The Portsmouth Navy Yard at Portsmouth, New Hampshire was selected to convert and outfit these vessels into Q Ships.
To detect submarines, they were equipped with WEA echo-ranging and listening equipment.
To withstand one or two torpedo hits they would be loaded with pulp wood logs or empty steel drums for extra buoyancy.
To attack submarines, they were armed with four four-inch-fifty caliber guns, four .50 caliber machine guns, six depth charge throwers, small arms Lewis .30 caliber machine guns, sawed off shot guns, .45 automatic, and hand grenades.
The SS Evelyn was commissioned the USS Asterion (AK-100) and the SS Carolyn was commissioned the USS Atik (AK-101) on March 5, 1942, at the Portsmouth Navy Yard, at Portsmouth, New Hampshire.
The MS WAVE was a fishing beam trawler originally acquired for conversion to an auxiliary minesweeper and commissioned Eagle V (AM-132) on March 5, 1942, at Portsmouth, New Hampshire. She was selected for duty as a Q ship because a fishing trawler could operate with the fishing fleet close to the fishing lanes used by the North Atlantic convoys. She was subsequently reclassified as the USS Captor (PYC-40).
These three ships formed a Special Task Group under the Chief of Naval Operations for the shakedown and training period. The commanding officer of Submarine Division 101 was the temporary commander.
Personnel
The officers and enlisted men selected for Q ships were all volunteers from the US Navy and the US Navy Reserve. The commanding officers are listed below.
Lieutenant Commander Harry Lynnwood Hicks, USN, Class of 1927, USNA, was selected as the commanding officer of the USS Atik (AK-101). The ship’s complement was 6 officers and 135 enlisted men.
Lieutenant Commander Glenn Walker Legwen Jr., USN, Class of 1927, USNA, was selected as the commanding officer of the USS Asterion (AK-101). The ship’s complement was 6 officers and 135 enlisted men.
Lieutenant Commander L. F. Rogers, USNR, was selected as the commanding officer of the USS Captor (PYC-40). The ship’s complement was 5 officers and 42 enlisted men.
Commander Joseph Aloysious Gainard, USNR, was selected as the commanding officer of the USS Bighorn (AO-45). Commander Louis C. Farley, USN, relieved Captain Gainard on June 24, 1943. The ship’s complement was 13 officers and 157 enlisted men.
Lieutenant Commander Richard Parmenter, USNR, was selected as the commanding officer of the Irene Forsyte (IX-93). The ship’s complement was 5 officers and 31 enlisted men.
Loss of the USS Atik (AK101)
The Special Task Group of Atik (AK-101), Asterion (AK-100), and Eagle V (AM-132) reported to the Commander Submarine Division 101 as ready for sea. The Special Task Group was transferred from Commander, Submarine Division 101, to Commander, Eastern Sea Frontier.
They got underway at 1300 hours on March 23, 1942, from Portsmouth Naval Yard and appeared as an armed vessel of the US Navy. Soon after leaving port, Atik, Asterion and Eagle went their separate ways on their shakedown cruise.
The Atik and Asterion turned into decoy ships and appeared to be tankers. Guns and depth charge throwers were concealed, Navy identifying numbers were removed from the bows and commission pennants taken down. The crew changed into civilian clothes or merchant marine uniforms.
Three days later the Atik was in the general area about 300 miles east of Norfolk, Virginia. German U-boat U-123 began stalking her and fired one torpedo that struck the ship on her port side, under the bridge.
At 2053 hours on March 26, 1942 radio stations at Manasquan, New Jersey, and at Fire Island, New York, intercepted the following distress message:
“SSS SOS Lat. 36-00 N, Long. 70-00 W, Carolyn burning forward, not bad.”
Two minutes later, a second distress message: “Torpedo attack, burning forward; require assistance.”
The duty officer in the control room at Eastern Sea Frontier was not informed that the SS Carolyn was a Q ship. Distress messages sent by merchant vessels from this area were routine and all available surface craft were on patrol, so he forwarded the message to Cominch.
On the Atik she steered a course parallel to the enemy submarine and as designed, opened fire from her main and secondary batteries. “The first 4-inch shell splashed short of the U-boat, as she made off presenting a small target; the shots that followed were off in deflection. Heavy .50-caliber machine gun fire, though, ricocheted around the U-boat’s decks as she bent on speed to escape the trap.
At 0037 hours, on March 27, another torpedo struck the Atik on her port side, under the bridge.
The U-boat pulled out of range submerged and at 0229 hours, fired another torpedo into Atik’smachinery spaces. The Atik badly damaged settled by the bow, her single screw now out of the water.
The Atik’smen could be seen embarking in her lifeboats.
The U-123 surfaced at 0327 hours, to finish off Q-ship, but suddenly at 0350 hours, a cataclysmic explosion blew Atik to pieces. Anyone left on board was killed by enemy action. Any crew members that made it into lifeboats or in the water faced severe weather and heavy seas.
Several hours later, the duty officer in the operations room at Cominch in a telephone call to the duty officer at the operations room at Eastern Sea Frontier discovered the commanding officer of the Eastern Sea Frontier nor the Navy Chief of Staff had been notified.
Early the next morning, on March 27, 1942, a US Army Air Forces bomber was sent to search the area but found nothing. The destroyer USS Noa (DD-343) and the USS Sagamore (AT-20) were sent to the area. Sagamore was recalled on March 28, 1942, due to bad weather. Noa remained and sighted some wreckage from Atik.
On April 9, 1942, a broadcast made from the High Command in Berlin claimed 13 vessels were sunk off the American East coast to include a bitter battle with a Q-boat that it was sent to the bottom by a U-boat.
The Atik was declared missing in action on March 27, 1942, and declared lost on April 27, 1942, and the next of kin of the crew were notified. Lieutenant Commander Harry L. Hicks, USN, the commanding officer, five officers, and 135 enlisted men were lost without a trace.
The crew of the Atik were awarded the Purple Heart (posthumously) and the American Area Campaign Medal with one battle star.
The Atik (SS Carolyn) was awarded the American Area Campaign Medal and one battle for her battle on March 27, 1942, with U-123.
Q Ships
The USS Asterion (AK-100) first cruise completed her shakedown cruise on April 18, 1942, with several sound contacts with U-boats, sighting of torpedoed merchant vessels and lifeboats, and the rescue of survivors. The second cruise as a decoy ship began on May 4, 1942, and she appeared as a straggler from a convoy, but it was uneventful. Four more cruises were made between June 7, 1942, and January 19, 1943. Asterion was discontinued as a decoy ship on October 14, 1943, and was subsequently converted for use as a weather-vessel in the North Atlantic.
The Eagle V (AM-132) was reclassified as the USS Captor (PYC-40). The first cruise began on May 26, 1942, and operated in the general vicinity of Georges Bank with the beam trawler fishing fleet out of Boston, Massachusetts. Captor operated as a Q ship for the next twelve months but didn’t have any engagements with the enemy. She was reclassified as a regular armed patrol craft and assigned to the First Naval District.
The SS Gulf Dawn was the fourth Q ship converted first at the Brooklyn Yard and completed on July 22, 1942, at the Navy Yard Boston. She was commissioned the USS Bighorn (AO-45) and conducted training, a shakedown cruise, and final repairs. The first cruise began on September 27, 1942, from New York to Guantanamo, Cuba with no enemy action. On October 16, 1942, Big Horn sailed in convoy T-19 from Trinidad to the point of separation. Three U-boats attacked the convoy at 1520 hours, but the Bighorn was reportedly not able to attack. She acted as a decoy straggler for three more cruises with no action against the enemy.
A newly organized task group was organized in February 1942 that consisted of Big Horn, PC-560, PC-617 and PC-618. Convoy UGS 7A sailed on April 14, 1943, to the vicinity of the Azores where the task group left the convoy to act as a straggler with escorts. The Big Horn attacked three U-boats and reported one as presumed sunk. The Big Horn as a decoy ship with PC-618 and PC 617 acting as escorts departed on July 27, 1943, from Norfolk, Virginia with convoy UGS-13 enroute to the vicinity of the Azores. The Big Horn acted as a decoy in the vicinity of the Azores in August and September with sightings of U-boats but no enemy contact. The cruise was completed on October 7, 1943. The Big Horn with PC-617 and PC-618, returned on November 27, 1943, to the Azores. They recorded nine contacts, sightings or attacks on U-boats in the vicinity. They returned on December 31, 1943, to Cape Cod Bay.
The Big Horn was reclassified as a regular armed patrol craft and assigned to North Atlantic Weather Patrol Duty in the North Atlantic under the supervision of the Coast Guard and manned by Coast Guard officers and crew.
The Canadian three-masted schooner named Irene Myrlte was the fifth Q ship commissioned USS Irene Forsyte (IX-93). The vessel was converted at Thames Shipyard, New London, Connecticut. Irene Forsyte departed on or about September 26, 1943, and ran into heavy weather, a material failure caused it to be unseaworthy, and she put in at Bermuda for repairs.
End of Project LQ
The Board of Investigation appointed to investigate the material failure in the Irene Forsyte concluded the following:
“The conversion of USS Irene Forsyte is an instance of misguided conception and misdirected zeal, which, coupled with inefficiency resulting from lack of supervision by competent authority, has cost the government nearly half a million dollars in money and a serious waste of effort. In addition, much valuable material that can ultimately be used has been frozen for the better part of one year.”
“The practice of granting to Frontier Commander and District Commandants uncontrolled authority to implement projects of this nature has been discontinued.”
Admiral King cancelled Project LQ and the use of Q-ships in the Eastern Sea Frontier during World War II ended.
Sources
Dictionary of American Naval Fighting Ships (DANFS) at the Naval History and Heritage Command.
Index of Purple Heart Award Recipients, 1942-1950. NAID: 6424319. Records of the Bureau of Naval Personnel, Record Group 24. National Archives at College Park, College Park, Maryland.
Muster Rolls of U.S. Navy Ships, Stations, and Other Naval Activities, 01/01/1939-01/01/1949. A-1 Entry 135, 10230 rolls, NAID: 594996. Records of the Bureau of Naval Personnel, Record Group 24. National Archives at College Park, College Park, Maryland.
USS Atik Press Release, January 3, 1946. NAID: 77618322. World War II War Diaries, Other Operational Records and Histories, Record Group 38: Records of the Office of the Chief of Naval Operations. National Archives at College Park, College Park, Maryland.
War Diary, Eastern Sea Frontier, October 1943. NAID: 78348337. World War II War Diaries, Other Operational Records and Histories, Record Group 38: Records of the Office of the Chief of Naval Operations, National Archives at College Park, College Park, Maryland.
War Diary, Submarine Division One Hundred One, March 15-31, 1942. NAID: 133887025. World War II War Diaries, Other Operational Records and Histories, Record Group 38: Records of the Office of the Chief of Naval Operations, National Archives at College Park, College Park, Maryland.



